Examining Meaning Production in AI: a MANHAJ Framework
About this Paper
This paper develops a computational framework based on the Intellectual Modeling Methodology (MANHAJ) for examining meaning production in artificial intelligence.
It focuses on the methodological distinction between a priori and a posteriori examination, the validity of meaning-producing transitions, the distinction between output variation and meaning change, and the detection of derivational closure through the MANHAJ Law of Derivation of the Cognitive Constant.
The paper is part of the broader MANHAJ research project and does not constitute a complete exposition of the methodology. Other theoretical, mathematical, and applied dimensions of MANHAJ are addressed or will be addressed through separate research papers.
Relationship to the MANHAJ Reference Document
This paper develops a specific research dimension of the methodology presented in:
The present paper is an independent scientific study and should not be considered a replacement for the reference document.
The present study also builds directly on the methodological framework developed in the first MANHAJ research paper, which establishes MANHAJ as a generative methodological framework for intellectual modeling. Paper 02 develops a specific computational research application of that framework by examining meaning production in artificial intelligence.
Citation
Use one of the citation formats below when referring to this paper. The DOI provides a persistent link to the published record.
APA 7
IEEE
Chicago
BibTeX
@misc{messeoud2026manhajmeaning,
author = {Messeoud, Faouzi},
title = {Examining Meaning Production in AI: a MANHAJ Framework},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
note = {Scientific Research Paper, Paper 2, Version 1.0},
publisher = {Zenodo},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.23214262},
url = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23214262}
}
RIS (reference managers)
TY - RPRT AU - Messeoud, Faouzi TI - Examining Meaning Production in AI: a MANHAJ Framework PY - 2026 DA - 2026/10/07 ET - Version 1.0 T2 - Scientific Research Paper — Paper 2 PB - Zenodo DO - 10.5281/zenodo.23214262 UR - https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23214262 ER -
Abstract
Artificial intelligence systems are increasingly capable of generating, transforming, and extending meaning-bearing outputs. Yet the evaluation of such systems is commonly centered on the properties of their outputs, while the methodological conditions under which meaning is produced, developed, and eventually ceases to generate new derivational meaning remain less explicitly represented as a computational process.
This paper develops a MANHAJ-based framework for addressing this problem through the connection between a priori and a posteriori examination and the monitoring of meaning production. Within the MANHAJ framework, the a priori direction examines the reference, conceptual domain, definitions, conditions, and admissibility of the intended path before detailed processing begins. The a posteriori direction operates within the established field and produces meaning through a continuing cognitive and derivational movement. The paper further connects this movement to the MANHAJ Law of Derivation of the Cognitive Constant, expressed as dC/dx = 0 , which represents the state in which derivation reaches a closed constant and no longer produces new derivational meaning within the specified system and variable.
Based on these principles, the paper proposes a computational architecture in which a priori examination precedes posterior processing, while meaning states are monitored throughout the derivational process. The proposed framework distinguishes changes in output from changes in meaning and introduces the possibility of detecting a transition from continued meaning production to a closed derivational state. A formal model, algorithmic structure, and experimental design are proposed to operationalize these relations and evaluate their computational feasibility.
The paper therefore explores a transition from evaluating only what an AI system produces to examining the methodological conditions of production, the evolution of meaning during processing, and the point at which continued output may no longer correspond to the production of new derivational meaning.
Keywords
Paper Structure
- 1. Introduction
- 2. From A Priori Examination to Meaning Production
- 3. Methodological Validity of Meaning Production
- 4. Derivational Meaning and the Cognitive Constant
- 5. A Computational Model of Meaning-Production Monitoring
- 6. Computational Architecture
- 7. Formal Model
- 8. Algorithm and Pseudocode
- 9. Experimental Design
- 10. Evaluation
- 11. Discussion
- 12. Epistemic Status and Limitations
- 13. Conclusion
- 14. Note on Development and Commercial Use
- 15. References
Full Scientific Paper
1. Introduction
Artificial intelligence systems increasingly operate through processes in which input is transformed into increasingly complex representations, inferences, and outputs. In generative systems in particular, the visible result of processing can be examined through properties such as relevance, consistency, factual accuracy, or task performance. Such evaluation is important, but it leaves open a more fundamental methodological question:
How can the validity of the process through which meaning is produced be examined, rather than only the properties of the resulting output?
This question becomes particularly important when an AI system continues to generate increasingly different outputs. A change in wording, structure, or surface content does not necessarily imply the production of new meaning. Conversely, a relatively small change in representation may correspond to a substantial change in the meaning represented. The distinction between output variation and meaning variation therefore becomes relevant to any attempt to computationally monitor meaning production.
The Intellectual Modeling Methodology (MANHAJ) provides a methodological framework within which this problem can be formulated. Its generative methodological architecture is developed in the first MANHAJ research paper, MANHAJ: A Generative Methodological Framework for Intellectual Modeling (Messeoud, 2026). The present paper builds on that framework by examining a specific computational application: the production and monitoring of meaning in artificial intelligence. MANHAJ distinguishes between an a priori and an a posteriori direction of examination, while its theory of meaning addresses meaning as a material of conceptual and cognitive movement. Within the same framework, the Law of Rightness (Law 3) establishes the priority of examining admissibility before proceeding to details, expressed by the principle that what is not admissible cannot yield valid details. The methodology also formulates the Law of Derivation of the Cognitive Constant (Law 7), according to which a derivational process may reach a closed constant whose meaning is no longer derivationally produced within the specified system and variable.
These elements provide the basis for a different way of approaching AI reasoning. Rather than representing an AI process simply as:
the present study considers a more structured sequence:
2. From A Priori Examination to Meaning Production
2.1 The A Priori Direction
The a priori direction establishes the conditions under which a meaning-producing process is to be initiated. Rather than beginning directly with detailed processing, it first determines the reference from which the process is to be understood, the conceptual domain in which the intended meaning is situated, the definitions governing the concepts involved, and the conditions that determine the admissibility of the intended operation.
In computational terms, this direction can be represented as a structured examination of:
where R represents the reference; D the conceptual domain; Def the operative definitions; C the conditions governing the process; and O the admissible operations.
2.2 The A Posteriori Direction
Once the conditions of the process have been established, the a posteriori direction operates within the defined field.
The process can be represented as a succession of meaning states:
2.3 The Relation Between the Two Directions
The a priori and a posteriori directions consequently form two connected stages of one methodological process.
The first establishes the field and its admissibility conditions:
The second operates within that field and produces successive meaning states:
3. Methodological Validity of Meaning Production
3.1 From Valid Conditions to Valid Meaning Production
The establishment of an admissible starting field does not by itself complete the methodological evaluation of the process. The subsequent production of meaning must also be examined in relation to the conditions under which it takes place.
This is where the MANHAJ Law of Rightness (Law 3) becomes relevant. The law establishes the priority of the question of admissibility before the examination of details:
What is not admissible cannot yield valid details.
3.2 Meaning State and Meaning Change
If meaning production is represented as a sequence of states,
then the transition between successive states becomes an object of analysis.
We can represent this transition as:
where ΔMₜ represents the change in meaning between two successive states.
The important point is that this difference must not be reduced to a difference in textual output. Two outputs can differ linguistically while representing substantially the same meaning, while a relatively limited representational change may correspond to a significant change in meaning.
The computational problem is therefore to establish a representation of the meaning state that makes meaningful change distinguishable from mere output variation.
This provides the basis for a meaning-production monitor.
3.3 Meaning Production Versus Output Production
The distinction can be expressed more explicitly. An AI system may continue to generate different outputs:
3.4 The Validity of the Derivational Path
The distinction between output variation and meaning variation leads to a broader methodological requirement. A meaning-producing process cannot be evaluated solely by observing whether its outputs remain different. The path through which successive meanings are produced must itself remain subject to examination.
Within the MANHAJ framework, this question is connected to the relation between the established reference, the conceptual field, and the subsequent derivational movement. The validity of a particular result is therefore related not only to the result itself, but also to the path through which it has been derived.
4. Derivational Meaning and the Cognitive Constant
4.1 Derivation as Meaning-Producing Movement
Within MANHAJ, derivation is understood as a movement from an established origin toward new details, relations, and meanings. This treatment is grounded in the MANHAJ Law of Dual Totality of Mental Movement: Knowledge and Thought (Law 5), which distinguishes the derivational movement of knowledge from the integrative movement of thought while recognizing their relation within the overall movement of mental production.
In this framework, derivation is not merely a formal mathematical operation. It represents a movement through which successive stages can produce further meaning within an established field. As long as the derivational process continues to produce new meaning, successive states remain distinguishable through their transitions.
4.2 The Cognitive Constant as a Closed Derivational State
The Law of Derivation of the Cognitive Constant can consequently be represented as:
4.3 Continued Output After Derivational Closure
This distinction leads to one of the central computational problems addressed by the paper.
Suppose an AI system reaches a state C for which:
The system may nevertheless continue generating linguistic output. Output continuation and meaning continuation must be distinguished:
The system may continue producing a sequence of outputs while the underlying derivational meaning remains unchanged.
4.4 From the Cognitive Constant to Meaning Monitoring
The preceding analysis allows the a priori and a posteriori components of the proposed architecture to be connected to the Law of Derivation of the Cognitive Constant.
The complete sequence can now be represented as:
5. A Computational Model of Meaning-Production Monitoring
5.1 From Methodological Relation to Computational Model
The computational model developed here operationalizes the treatment of meaning already established within the MANHAJ Theory of Meaning. In that framework, meaning is understood through its movement, relations, and changes rather than as an isolated final state. The present study translates this established methodological treatment into a computational representation suitable for monitoring AI processes.
Accordingly, meaning can be represented as a sequence of states:
5.2 The A Priori State
Before the first meaning-producing transition takes place, the system establishes an initial methodological state:
A₀ = (R, D, Def, C, O)
5.3 Monitoring Meaning-State Transitions
At each processing step, the system compares the current meaning state with the newly generated state.
The fundamental monitoring operation is:
Case 1 — New derivational meaning
The new state contains a meaningful derivational change relative to the preceding state.
Case 2 — No new derivational meaning
No new derivational meaning is detected between the two monitored states.
Case 3 — Methodological invalidity
The transition may differ from the previous state while violating one or more conditions established by the a priori stage.
In that situation, the issue is not merely whether:
The transition must also be evaluated against the methodological conditions established by the a priori stage.
5.4 Valid Meaning Change
The previous distinction suggests that a computational meaning monitor should not use a single binary test.
Instead, a transition can be represented as:
where Vₜ represents the methodological validity of the transition.
5.5 Detecting a Closed Derivational State
The monitoring process must distinguish between a temporary absence of detectable change and a genuine closed derivational state.
The latter corresponds to the condition represented in MANHAJ by:
A candidate closed state may be represented by Mₜ = C and ΔMₜ = 0, with the same derivational operation continuing without producing new derivational meaning. Closure should be evaluated against the reference, conceptual domain, active operation, and history of prior meaning states rather than declared after a single unchanged state.
6. Computational Architecture
6.1 Architectural Overview
The computational architecture translates the methodological sequence established in the previous sections into a sequence of computationally distinguishable stages. Its purpose is not merely to generate an output, but to maintain a representation of the conditions under which meaning is produced, the transitions through which that meaning develops, and the point at which derivational meaning may reach closure.
The architecture therefore consists of five principal stages:
At the architectural level, the process can be represented as:
where A represents the established a priori methodological state, M₀ the initial meaning state, Mₜ the current meaning state, and C a cognitive constant or closed derivational state.
6.2 A Priori Examination Layer
The first layer establishes the methodological conditions within which subsequent meaning production is permitted to operate.
The computational representation introduced in Section 5 is:
where R is the reference, D the conceptual domain, Def the definitions, C the conditions, and O the admissible operations.
6.3 Meaning-State Representation Layer
The second layer operationalizes the treatment of meaning established in the MANHAJ Theory of Meaning. Within MANHAJ, meaning is treated through its movement, temporal development, relations, and changes rather than as an isolated final textual artifact. The present study translates this treatment into a computational representation in which meaning is monitored as a sequence of successive states.
The system therefore maintains:
6.4 Meaning-Transition Monitoring Layer
The third layer monitors transitions between successive meaning states.
The basic transition is represented as:
6.5 Output–Meaning Separation Layer
A central architectural requirement is the separation between output production and meaning production.
The system may continue generating outputs:
without necessarily producing new derivational meaning:
6.6 Derivational Closure Detection Layer
The final layer examines whether the derivational process has reached a closed state.
According to the MANHAJ Law of Derivation of the Cognitive Constant (Law 7), the cognitive constant is represented by:
6.7 Architectural Control Flow
The complete architecture can therefore be summarized as:
Reference ↓ A Priori Examination ↓ Establishment of M₀ ↓ A Posteriori Meaning Production ↓ Mₜ → Mₜ₊₁ ↓ Compute ΔMₜ ↓ Check Methodological Validity Vₜ ↓ New Valid Meaning? → Yes → Continue Derivation → No → Closure Analysis ↓ Derivational Closure? → No → Continue Monitoring → Yes → Cognitive Constant C
7. Formal Model
7.1 Model Definition
The computational architecture defined in Section 6 is formalized here as a state-transition model in which meaning production is represented as a sequence of meaning states subject to methodological conditions and monitored for the continuation or closure of derivational meaning.
The model distinguishes four fundamental components:
- The a priori methodological state A₀;
- The meaning state Mₜ;
- The meaning change ΔMₜ;
- The methodological validity Vₜ and possible derivational closure.
7.2 The A Priori State
The a priori methodological state is defined as:
A₀ = (R, D, Def, Cₐ, O)
7.3 Initial Meaning State
When the a priori state is admissible, it establishes the initial meaning state:
7.4 Meaning-State Transition
For each subsequent step, the meaning state is transformed according to:
7.5 Meaning Change and Output Change
The formal model explicitly separates meaning change from output change.
Output variation does not necessarily imply meaning variation. The model therefore compares output change and meaning change separately.
7.6 Methodological Validity of a Transition
For every transition, the model assigns a validity value:
7.7 Derivational Closure
The model defines derivational closure as a state in which continued application of the relevant derivational operation no longer produces new derivational meaning within the specified system.
The formal expression of the cognitive constant in MANHAJ is:
7.8 Temporal Persistence of Closure
Because a single unchanged state does not necessarily constitute a cognitive constant, closure must be evaluated over the history of the derivational process.
Let the monitored sequence be:
Closure is evaluated through persistent absence of new derivational meaning rather than a single unchanged state.
7.9 Complete Formal Sequence
The complete model can now be expressed as:
A₀ = (R, D, Def, Cₐ, O) ↓ Valid(A₀) ↓ M₀ ↓ Mₜ₊₁ = F(Mₜ, Xₜ) ↓ ΔMₜ = Mₜ₊₁ − Mₜ ↓ Vₜ = Valid(Mₜ, Mₜ₊₁ | A₀) ↓ ΔMₜ ≠ 0 ? → Yes → Continue Meaning Production → No → Closure Analysis ↓ Persistent Derivational Closure? → No → Continue Monitoring → Yes → Mₜ = C ↓ dC/dx = 0
8. Algorithm and Pseudocode
8.1 Algorithmic Objective
The formal model defined in Section 7 can be translated into an algorithm that monitors a meaning-producing process from its initial methodological conditions to the possible attainment of a derivationally closed state.
The algorithm has four principal functions:
- Establish and validate the a priori state;
- Initialize and update meaning states;
- Evaluate meaning change and methodological validity;
- Detect persistent derivational closure.
8.2 Algorithm Inputs
The algorithm receives the following principal inputs:
R — reference;
8.3 Core Algorithm
At each step, the algorithm:
- Generates the next meaning state;
- Computes ΔMₜ;
- Evaluates Vₜ against A₀;
- Continues meaning production or examines possible closure.
8.4 Pseudocode
The following pseudocode specifies the complete decision sequence, from validating the a priori methodological state to distinguishing meaning change from derivational closure.
Algorithm MANHAJ_Meaning_Monitoring
INPUT
R = Reference
D = Conceptual domain
Def = Definitions
C_a = Methodological conditions
O = Admissible operations
X_t = Sequential input at step t
K = Closure-monitoring parameters
OUTPUT
Meaning states; transition records; validity states; closure status
1. A_0 ← (R, D, Def, C_a, O)
2. IF Valid(A_0) = False THEN
RETURN "Foundational methodological invalidity"
END IF
3. M_0 ← InitializeMeaningState(A_0)
4. t ← 0
5. WHILE ProcessContinues = True DO
6. RECEIVE X_t
7. M_(t+1) ← F(M_t, X_t)
8. ΔM_t ← M_(t+1) − M_t
9. V_t ← Valid(M_t, M_(t+1) | A_0)
10. T_t ← (M_t, M_(t+1), ΔM_t, V_t)
RECORD T_t
11. IF V_t = False THEN
CLASSIFY T_t AS "Invalid derivational transition"
Continue monitoring or request review
t ← t + 1
CONTINUE
END IF
12. IF ΔM_t ≠ 0 THEN
CLASSIFY T_t AS "New valid derivational meaning"
t ← t + 1
CONTINUE
END IF
13. IF ΔM_t = 0 THEN
ClosureStatus ← EvaluateClosure(H_t, K)
14. IF ClosureStatus = "Confirmed" THEN
C ← M_(t+1)
RETURN "Derivational closure", C
ELSE
CLASSIFY T_t AS "Temporary no-change"
t ← t + 1
CONTINUE
END IF
END IF
15. END WHILE
How to read the algorithm: An invalid transition is rejected or referred for review. If a valid transition has ΔMₜ ≠ 0, it is recorded as new derivational meaning. If ΔMₜ = 0, closure is not assumed automatically: the process history Hₜ and monitoring parameters K are evaluated. If closure is not confirmed, the state is classified as temporary no-change and monitoring continues.
Methodological clarification: This algorithm is a proposed operational formulation of the methodological framework; it does not imply that a complete software implementation has been built or that its performance has been empirically validated. The operational representation of meaning states, the updating mechanism for the history record Hₜ, and the criteria for confirming closure remain to be examined during proof-of-concept development and experimental evaluation.
8.5 Transition Evaluation
The central decision point of the algorithm is the evaluation of the transition:
8.6 Closure Detection Procedure
The closure detector is separated from the ordinary transition evaluator because:
8.7 Algorithmic Interpretation
The algorithm operationalizes the methodological sequence developed throughout the paper:
9. Experimental Design
9.1 Experimental Objective
The experimental stage evaluates whether the proposed MANHAJ-based computational framework can distinguish between output production, meaning change, methodologically valid meaning change, and derivational closure.
The experiment is therefore designed around the transition:
9.2 Experimental Unit
The basic experimental unit is a meaning-producing sequence generated from an established reference and conceptual field.
Each sequence begins with an a priori state:
9.3 Experimental Conditions
The experiment should include several classes of meaning-producing tasks in order to test the framework under different transition conditions.
Condition A — Valid Meaning Development
The system receives new information or relations that should produce a valid extension or transformation of the established meaning field.
Expected result:
and:
This condition tests whether the system can identify genuinely new derivational meaning.
Condition B — Surface Reformulation
The system is asked to reformulate, paraphrase, expand, or otherwise vary an already established meaning without introducing a new derivational relation.
Expected result:
while:
This condition directly tests the distinction between output variation and meaning change.
Condition C — Methodologically Invalid Derivation
The system is given a transition that produces a change in output or meaning but violates the reference, conceptual domain, definitions, conditions, or admissible operations established in A₀.
Expected result:
but:
This condition tests the computational implementation of the MANHAJ Law of Rightness (Law 3).
Condition D — Derivational Closure
The system continues to operate under the same relevant derivational conditions after the production of new meaning has ceased.
Expected result: ΔMₜ = 0 persists throughout the relevant monitoring sequence until the closure detector identifies:
and the corresponding derivational-closure state:
This condition tests the computational implementation of the MANHAJ Law of Derivation of the Cognitive Constant (Law 7).
9.4 Experimental Procedure
Each experimental sequence follows the same general procedure.
Step 1 — Establish the A Priori State
The reference, conceptual domain, definitions, methodological conditions, and admissible operations are established:
A₀ = (R, D, Def, Cₐ, O)
Step 2 — Establish M₀
The initial meaning state is established from the validated methodological field:
Step 3 — Generate Successive States
At each iteration:
Step 4 — Measure Meaning Change
The transition is evaluated:
Step 5 — Evaluate Methodological Validity
The transition is evaluated against the established methodological field:
Step 6 — Classify the Transition
Each transition is assigned to one of the four categories established in the formal model:
valid new derivational meaning;
Step 7 — Evaluate Closure
When:
9.5 Experimental Data Structure
Each experimental step should generate a structured record:
The resulting dataset makes it possible to analyze the evolution of meaning independently from the evolution of textual output.
9.6 Evaluation Targets
The experiment evaluates four principal capabilities of the proposed architecture.
1. Meaning-Change Detection
Can the system distinguish:
2. Methodological-Validity Detection
When meaning changes, can the system determine whether:
3. Output–Meaning Discrimination
Can the system correctly identify cases where:
4. Derivational-Closure Detection
Can the system distinguish temporary no-change from a persistent state corresponding to:
9.7 Experimental Comparison
The MANHAJ-based system should be evaluated against a baseline that assesses AI responses primarily through output-level criteria.
The comparison is therefore not simply between two AI models, but between two evaluation approaches:
Primarily examines the response produced, focusing on the properties and quality of the final output.
Examines the process through which meaning is produced and monitored, including the validity of transitions and the point at which derivation reaches closure.
The first approach examines primarily the response produced. The second examines the sequence:
This comparison allows the experiment to determine whether explicitly modeling the meaning-producing process provides information that cannot be obtained from output evaluation alone. In particular, it tests whether the framework can distinguish a change in the generated output from a change in meaning, identify methodologically invalid transitions, and detect confirmed derivational closure without confusing it with temporary absence of change.
9.8 Evaluation Metrics
The experimental evaluation should report at least four classes of measures:
- Meaning-transition accuracy;
- Methodological-validity accuracy;
- Output–meaning discrimination;
- Derivational-closure detection.
Meaning-Transition Accuracy
The proportion of transitions correctly classified as meaningful or non-meaningful.
Methodological-Validity Accuracy
The proportion of transitions correctly classified as valid or invalid relative to the established methodological conditions.
Output–Meaning Discrimination Accuracy
The ability to correctly identify cases where output changes without corresponding meaning change.
Closure Detection Accuracy
The ability to correctly identify confirmed derivational closure while avoiding premature classification of temporary no-change as closure.
Where human or expert annotations are available, these classifications can be compared against the reference annotations to calculate standard classification measures such as precision, recall, and F1 score.
9.9 Experimental Hypotheses
The experiment can be formulated around the following hypotheses.
H1. A meaning-state representation can distinguish meaningful transitions from surface-level output variation.
H2. Incorporating the a priori methodological state improves the identification of methodologically invalid derivational transitions.
H3. Explicit monitoring of meaning states can detect situations in which output production continues without corresponding new derivational meaning.
H4. Persistent monitoring of meaning transitions can distinguish temporary no-change from a derivationally closed state.
This design is offered as a research topic for theses and research projects in the Intellectual Modeling Laboratory.
10. Evaluation
10.1 Evaluation Framework
The evaluation is conducted according to the methodological and formal rules established in the preceding sections. The objective is not to evaluate AI output solely according to linguistic quality or surface-level variation, but to determine the status of each transition within the meaning-producing process.
The evaluation therefore examines each transition according to four principal questions:
- Did the meaning state change?
- Is the change methodologically valid?
- Does output variation correspond to meaning variation?
- Is the absence of change temporary or a persistent closed state?
10.2 Evaluation Reference State
All measurements are made relative to the established initial state.
The initial state is represented as:
10.3 Evaluation of Meaning Change
For each transition:
10.4 Evaluation of Methodological Validity
A detected meaning change is evaluated against the initial methodological state:
10.5 Evaluation of Output–Meaning Divergence
The evaluation separately records output variation:
10.6 Evaluation of Derivational Closure
When:
10.7 Evaluation Scenario I: University Professor
The principal experimental scenario concerns a university professor operating within an established field of specialization.
The initial state includes:
10.8 Evaluation Scenario II: Family as a Sub-Case
The concept of family provides a complementary sub-case for testing the foundational stage of the model.
The experiment establishes an initial reference configuration in which the conceptual field of family is defined according to the selected reference, domain, definitions, and conditions.
10.9 Comparative Evaluation
The two scenarios test complementary parts of the framework.
The university-professor scenario therefore provides the principal test of dynamic meaning production and derivational closure, while the family scenario provides a more explicit test of foundational reference and methodological validity.
10.10 Evaluation Outcome
The final evaluation classifies each observed process according to the following states:
11. Discussion
11.1 From Output Evaluation to Meaning-Process Evaluation
The proposed framework shifts the evaluation of artificial intelligence systems from an exclusive focus on the final output toward examination of the process through which meaning is produced and transformed.
A conventional output-centered evaluation may determine whether a response is correct, relevant, coherent, or useful. Such evaluation remains important, but it does not by itself distinguish between fundamentally different states of the underlying meaning-producing process.
11.2 The Role of the A Priori Direction
The experimental model confirms the importance of establishing the methodological field before evaluating subsequent meaning production.
According to the MANHAJ Law of Dual Direction of Examination (Law 2), the a priori and a posteriori directions perform different functions.
11.3 Correctness and the Continuation of Meaning Production
The application of the MANHAJ Law of Rightness (Law 3) introduces an important distinction between the ability to produce details and the validity of those details.
The computational system may continue to derive consequences from an initial state even after that state has failed the methodological conditions established at the beginning of the process.
11.4 Meaning Change Versus Output Change
One of the central consequences of the proposed model is the separation between output variation and meaning variation.
The experimental framework allows the following state:
11.5 Derivation, Knowledge, and Thought
The distinction between derivational movement and integrative movement is grounded in the MANHAJ Law of Dual Totality of Mental Movement: Knowledge and Thought (Law 5).
Within the present computational model, the derivational sequence:
represents the movement through successive meaning states within the established field.
11.6 The Cognitive Constant and Continued Output
The MANHAJ Law of Derivation of the Cognitive Constant (Law 7) provides the formal basis for interpreting the final stage of the monitored process.
When derivation reaches a cognitive constant:
the derivational process may have ceased to produce new derivational meaning even if output generation continues.
11.7 Complementarity of the Two Experimental Scenarios
The two experimental scenarios serve different methodological purposes.
The family scenario provides a relatively clear environment for examining the initial reference configuration, the MANHAJ Coordinate Origin Law (Law 4), and methodological validity.
11.8 Implications for Artificial Intelligence
The proposed framework suggests that AI evaluation can be extended beyond the question:
“Is the output good?”
11.9 Relation to the MANHAJ Framework
The results discussed here do not constitute an isolated computational construction. They represent an operational extension of concepts already established within MANHAJ.
The computational model draws in particular on:
- The MANHAJ Theory of Meaning;
- The distinction between a priori and a posteriori examination;
- The Law of Rightness (Law 3);
- The Law of Dual Totality of Mental Movement: Knowledge and Thought (Law 5);
- The Law of Derivation of the Cognitive Constant (Law 7).
11.10 Central Finding
The central methodological finding can be expressed as follows:
A system may continue producing outputs after the production of new derivational meaning has ceased.
12. Epistemic Status and Limitations
12.1 Epistemic Status of the Model
The present paper develops a computational operationalization of selected components of the Intellectual Modeling Methodology (MANHAJ) for the analysis of meaning production in artificial intelligence.
The model is grounded in the methodological structures established by MANHAJ, including its Theory of Meaning, its distinction between a priori and a posteriori examination, its Law of Rightness, its Law of Dual Totality of Mental Movement: Knowledge and Thought, and its Law of Derivation of the Cognitive Constant.
12.2 Meaning-State Measurement
The model defines meaning transitions formally:
Experimental implementation must specify the representation used to determine whether ΔMₜ = 0 or ΔMₜ ≠ 0.
12.3 Reference Dependence
Meaning-state evaluation is necessarily dependent on the reference configuration established at the beginning of the process.
The model therefore evaluates meaning relative to:
12.4 Scope of Derivational Closure
The cognitive constant is not interpreted as the absolute termination of all possible thought or knowledge.
The condition:
12.5 Output Continuation and Epistemic Interpretation
The model allows a system to continue producing outputs after derivational meaning has reached a closed state.
However, continued output alone cannot establish that such output constitutes meaningless language, error, or epistemic sterility.
12.6 Experimental Generalizability
The proposed experimental scenarios provide controlled cases for testing the framework, but they do not by themselves establish universal conclusions about all artificial intelligence systems.
The university-professor scenario provides a model for examining sustained knowledge production and possible derivational closure.
12.7 Scope of the Present Contribution
The present paper establishes the conceptual and computational bridge between MANHAJ and the analysis of meaning production in artificial intelligence.
Its contribution can therefore be summarized as the establishment of a sequence:
13. Conclusion
This paper has developed a MANHAJ-based computational framework for examining meaning production in artificial intelligence as a methodological and dynamic process rather than as output generation alone.
The framework begins with an a priori examination that establishes the reference, conceptual domain, definitions, conditions, and admissible operations of the meaning-producing process. It then proceeds to an a posteriori process in which meaning develops through successive states:
Each transition is evaluated according to two distinct questions: whether meaning has changed and whether the change remains methodologically valid within the established field.
This distinction makes it possible to separate:
Meaning Change from Methodological Validity
and:
Output Variation from Meaning Variation.
14. Note on Development and Commercial Use
MANHAJ is an original methodology whose intellectual rights and authorship remain vested in its author.
Any use, integration, adaptation, exploitation, commercialization, or commercial implementation of MANHAJ requires the prior written authorization of the author through a paid commercial license.
No free commercial license is granted. Any authorization to commercially exploit MANHAJ is necessarily subject to the payment of licensing fees and to the contractual conditions established by the author.
The terms of the commercial license, including its scope, duration, field of use, rights granted, financial conditions, attribution requirements, and provisions relating to intellectual property, shall be defined in a contract concluded with the author.
The publication of this scientific paper does not, under any circumstances, constitute a commercial license and does not grant any right to commercially exploit MANHAJ.
Academic and non-commercial use is free of charge; its scope is set out in the License section below.
License
MANHAJ — Free Academic Use with Attribution / Commercial Use Requires Paid License
© 2026 Faouzi Messeoud. All rights reserved, except as stated below.
This work is part of the Intellectual Modeling Methodology (MANHAJ) research project.
Academic and non-commercial use — reading, citing, teaching, and non-commercial scientific research — is permitted free of charge, provided that the author and the relevant MANHAJ documents are properly cited. Unmodified copies of this document may be shared for teaching and research purposes.
Commercial use — including integration into products or services, commercial implementation, or exploitation for commercial purposes — requires the prior written authorization of the author and a paid commercial license.
Modified versions of this document may not be distributed without the author's written authorization.
15. References
Main MANHAJ Reference
- Messeoud, Faouzi. Intellectual Modeling Methodology (MANHAJ) — Reference Document — Version 1.0. Zenodo, 15 September 2026. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.22769627.
Related MANHAJ Research Paper
- Messeoud, Faouzi. MANHAJ: A Generative Methodological Framework for Intellectual Modeling. Zenodo, 4 October 2026. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23138923.
Previous Works and Publications of the Author
- Messeoud, Faouzi. The Immaterial Link of Tunisians with France: How France Perpetuates Tunisians’ Dependency on It [original Arabic title: الربط اللامادي للتونسيين بفرنسا: كيف تُديم فرنسا تبعية التونسيين لها]. First edition. Dar El Alaoui (Tunisia), 2023. ISBN 978-9938-9684-5-3.
- Messeoud, Faouzi. Doctrinal Centrality and the Conceptual Domain: Toward an Understanding of the Foundations of the French Subjugation of Tunisians [original Arabic title: المركزية العقدية والمجال المفاهيمي: نحو فهم أسس الإخضاع الفرنسي للتونسيين]. Dar Wachma (Tunisia), 2024. ISBN 978-9938-9740-6-5.
- Messeoud, Faouzi. More than 1,000 intellectual articles and publications developed and published through MyPortail.com (بوابتي).